Is it better to destroy or join the Dark Brotherhood?

Joining Dark Brotherhood will give you the chance to enjoy the best storyline in Skyrim. Destroying them won't result in much, but you can take the alterego of being the Hero of Justice to slaughter them. It's a game where you can do both. So enjoy them.

Is there any benefit to destroying the Dark Brotherhood?

Destroying the Dark Brotherhood makes a number of rewards unavailable, namely Shadowmere, the Summon Spectral Assassin power, the never-dying Dark Brotherhood Initiate followers, or the Master trainers for Alchemy and Light Armor, and Cicero's offer of being a follower.

Is there a downside to joining Dark Brotherhood?

The Dark Brotherhood's greatest drawback is its merciless killing of many characters. Players may find their favorite merchant or bard becoming their next target. Many charming characters, such as Lurbuk, must be killed to progress the guild's main questline.

Who should I kill to join the Dark Brotherhood?

Killing Astrid will initiate “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!” Note that if you don't kill Astrid here, all the members of the Brotherhood become un-killable.

Would a good character join the Dark Brotherhood?

I guess the main take-away from my experience would be this: a 'good' character would never join the Dark Brotherhood, but leaving the Dark Brotherhood can be the first step a 'bad' character takes toward becoming a 'good' character. Skyrim offers plenty of milestones on the road to redemption.

Why You Should NOT Join The Dark Brotherhood

Can you marry someone in the Dark Brotherhood?

Muiri from Markarth, for example, will only be interested if you kill Nilsine Shatter-Shield in the Dark Brotherhood Quest Morning Never Comes. You can marry anyone, so long as they are interested. There are no restrictions on race or sexual orientation.

Should I join the Brotherhood of Steel or not?

The Brotherhood has no trouble supplying its constituency with enough firepower and armor to start an epic conflict. If you tend to think that eliminating and killing entire populations of Synth and other Mutants is justified, then the Brotherhood of Steel may be suitable for you.

Does it matter who you kill for Astrid?

A hooded woman known as Astrid tells you that she is from the Dark Brotherhood and that you owe a debt to them.To repay it, you must simply kill one of the three captives in the shack (to kill one is optional) . Kill all three to impress Astrid if you want.

Who does Astrid want me to kill?

While it's almost certain they all had contracts out on them, Astrid does prefer you killing one particular person over the others: Vasha, the Khajit, describes himself as a murderer, a rapist, and a thief. If you kill him, Astrid remarks that he was the obvious choice.

Can you become leader of the Dark Brotherhood?

A grand total of five different factions let you become the leader of the entire faction in Skyrim, including the four main factions (The Companions, The College of Winterhold, The Dark Brotherhood, and the Thieves Guild) and the vampiric Volkihar Clan in the Dawnguard DLC.

Is there any point in doing Dark Brotherhood forever?

does it end or will I kill everyone before it stops? It goes on forever, the NPC's that exist in those quests are only there for the purpose of completing the mission. They will never ask you to kill any named NPC. Those NPC's exist only to be murdered.

What happens if you refuse to join the Brotherhood of Steel?

If you dislike the Brotherhood, you can choose not to join and you'll always be able to change your mind or continue with the questline. Also, joining any faction will not cause you to become enemies with another until you reach a breaking point in that questline (such as the Mass Fusion quest and End of the Line).

Should I wipe out the brotherhood?

So, most of the players consider the Minutemen ending as the best for Fallout 4, because it keep alive both BoS and Railroad. But from the perspective of lore, you should destroy the Brotherhood, because their conflict with Minutemen is inevitable.

What happens to Babette if you Destroy the Dark Brotherhood?

Though she is an adult according to her dialogue, the game still categorizes her as a child NPC; thus, she can not be harmed. Babette won't be in the sanctuary if you choose to destroy the Dark Brotherhood during the first meeting with Astrid.

Can you still get Shadowmere if you Destroy the Dark Brotherhood?

No. The quest "Destroying the Dark Brotherhood" activates only if you attack Astrid in the Abandoned Hut, before you join the Dark Beotherhood. It is impossible to get Shadowmere or Cicero after that.

When should I start Dark Brotherhood Skyrim?

After completing the first quest, Innocence Lost, you will have to wait 24 hours before the Dark Brotherhood contacts you again. Sleep in a bed and the Brotherhood will abduct you and take you to a strange shack, with 3 hostages and an Assassin named Astrid. All you need to do is kill one of the hostages and you're in.

Does Astrid always betray you?

The Falkreath sanctuary is one of the last surviving headquarters of the Brotherhood, led by a woman known as Astrid. She's the one who will recruit the Dragonborn, and also ultimately betray them in a struggle for control and power over the Brotherhood's leadership.

Why does Astrid betray you?

However, it turns out that Astrid, fearing that her leadership of the Dark Brotherhood was threatened by the Dragonborn being the new Listener for the Night Mother, betrays them and reports the assassination attempt to the Penitus Oculatus and Maro himself, in return for amnesty and protection of the Dark Brotherhood.

Which of the 3 captives should I kill in Skyrim?

In truth, it doesn't matter which captive(s) you choose. You won't encounter any of them again (unless you return to the shack, and even then you won't be able to learn more). If you kill one or more of them, Astrid will give you the password to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary's "The Black Door".

Can you disobey Astrid and go to Volunruud?

You can directly go to Volunruud rather than speaking to Astrid first, but the quest won't start until she talks to you. There is a chest in Amaund's chamber within the ruins which is free to loot, containing some leveled valuables and gold.

Can I join the Dark Brotherhood if I kill Astrid?

Can you join the Dark Brotherhood after killing Astrid? No. The game immediately locks you into destroying the Dark Brotherhood if you killed her,the first time you met her.

Can you marry Astrid in Skyrim?

Without mods, no. Console commands won't do either. In order to be marriageable, an NPC needs to have a voice type that has the married lines recorded, and Astrid doesn't. Even if you add her to the correct factions and set her disposition, it won't work.

Do the Minutemen destroy the brotherhood?

Brotherhood of Steel gets betrayed and destroyed by the Minutemen - should the player character become hostile to the Brotherhood after the main quest is completed, the player character can ask the Minutemen to help them destroy the Brotherhood, just like in the Minutemen ending.

Who should I side with in Fallout 4?

Additionally, the enemies of the minutemen are silent enemies they do not kill everyone in their line of sight they hide and wait for the minutemen. All these reasons make the minutemen the best faction to join in fallout 4.

Is Brotherhood of Steel better than Minutemen?

Also, the weapons and equipment attained through the Minutemen cannot hope to compare to the likes of the Brotherhood of Steel, and their technological prowess pales in comparison to the Institute. While they may be seen as the good guys, they certainly are not the most powerful.