Is it better to kill Astrid or not?

Killing Astrid will initiate “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!” Note that if you don't kill Astrid here, all the members of the Brotherhood become un-killable. Upon Astrid's death, you'll be directed to inform a guard of what you've done.

What happens if you kill Astrid?

Killing the Khajiit may ease the consciences of some, but for others there is always the option of killing Astrid. Kill Astrid and you will find the key to escape the shack on her body, the quest for the Dark Brotherhood will come up as failed... dang. There goes that quest line.

Does it matter who you kill for Astrid?

No matter who you kill, and no matter if you kill all of them, Astrid will never confirm or deny that they were the correct choice, and this is left as a mystery since you don't even know if any of them even had a hit to start with.

Is it better to kill or join the Dark Brotherhood?

Joining Dark Brotherhood will give you the chance to enjoy the best storyline in Skyrim. Destroying them won't result in much, but you can take the alterego of being the Hero of Justice to slaughter them. It's a game where you can do both. So enjoy them.

Who should I kill for Astrid?

While it's almost certain they all had contracts out on them, Astrid does prefer you killing one particular person over the others: Vasha, the Khajit, describes himself as a murderer, a rapist, and a thief. If you kill him, Astrid remarks that he was the obvious choice.

Why You Should Kill Astrid | Hardest Decisions in Skyrim | Elder Scrolls Lore

Does Astrid always betray you?

The Falkreath sanctuary is one of the last surviving headquarters of the Brotherhood, led by a woman known as Astrid. She's the one who will recruit the Dragonborn, and also ultimately betray them in a struggle for control and power over the Brotherhood's leadership.

Which of the 3 captives should I kill in Skyrim?

In truth, it doesn't matter which captive(s) you choose. You won't encounter any of them again (unless you return to the shack, and even then you won't be able to learn more). If you kill one or more of them, Astrid will give you the password to the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary's "The Black Door".

Is there a downside to joining Dark Brotherhood?

The Dark Brotherhood's greatest drawback is its merciless killing of many characters. Players may find their favorite merchant or bard becoming their next target. Many charming characters, such as Lurbuk, must be killed to progress the guild's main questline.

Can you marry anyone in the Dark Brotherhood?

Muiri from Markarth, for example, will only be interested if you kill Nilsine Shatter-Shield in the Dark Brotherhood Quest Morning Never Comes. You can marry anyone, so long as they are interested. There are no restrictions on race or sexual orientation.

Can you be good and join the Dark Brotherhood?

Nevertheless, a prospective 'good' character can join both of these corrupt factions and dilligently work through their entire questlines provided they join a third faction - the Companions - at roughly the same time they join the Theives Guild, and progress far enough to become a werewolf before joining the Dark ...

How does Astrid betray you?

However, it turns out that Astrid, fearing that her leadership of the Dark Brotherhood was threatened by the Dragonborn being the new Listener for the Night Mother, betrays him and reports the assassination attempt to the Penitus Oculatus and Maro himself, in return for amnesty and protection of the Dark Brotherhood.

Can you ignore Astrid and go to Volunruud?

You can directly go to Volunruud rather than speaking to Astrid first, but the quest won't start until she talks to you. There is a chest in Amaund's chamber within the ruins which is free to loot, containing some leveled valuables and gold. If you go to Amaund before getting the quest, the quest will not be altered.

Can I get Shadowmere if I kill Astrid?

The simple answer to your question, without cheats, is no. The game is specifically scripted to give you Shadowmere once you have completed the Dark Brotherhoods quest related to the horse.

Can I marry Astrid?

In order to be marriageable, an NPC needs to have a voice type that has the married lines recorded, and Astrid doesn't. Even if you add her to the correct factions and set her disposition, it won't work. You have to use a mod to change her voice type.

Should you kill Astrid or Cicero?

The punishment for breaking the Tenets according to Sithis in Oblivion is expulsion from the Dark Brotherhood or death. This is why you must kill her Cicero is the head of the Dark Brotherhood not her.

Who is the most beneficial person to marry in Skyrim?

1. Argis the Bulwark Is the Best Skyrim Husband. After the Dragonborn proves themselves worth of becoming the Thane of Markarth, they gain Argis the Bulwark as their housecarl and potential husband alongside the opportunity to buy one of the most amazing prefab houses in the game.

Who is the best wife companion in Skyrim?

For anyone looking for a companion with their priorities set straight, Mjoll is the ideal marriage choice in Skyrim. She's a good-doer and dislikes anything that has to do with corruption, namely the Thieves' Guild and the Black-Briar family. Players will find her in Riften, usually hanging around the Bee and Barb Inn.

Can you become head of Dark Brotherhood?

A grand total of five different factions let you become the leader of the entire faction in Skyrim, including the four main factions (The Companions, The College of Winterhold, The Dark Brotherhood, and the Thieves Guild) and the vampiric Volkihar Clan in the Dawnguard DLC.

Can you get kicked out of the Dark Brotherhood?

There are several known ways to be banished by the Dark Brotherhood: Feeding on contract kills with the Ring of Namira equipped. Pickpocketing, killing, and/or feeding on a Dark Brotherhood member.

Should I wipe out the brotherhood?

So, most of the players consider the Minutemen ending as the best for Fallout 4, because it keep alive both BoS and Railroad. But from the perspective of lore, you should destroy the Brotherhood, because their conflict with Minutemen is inevitable.

Who is the hardest to kill in Skyrim?

Dwemer automatons are some of the most challenging enemies to deal with in Skyrim due to their high damage resistance and damage output. While the Centurions are difficult enough to fight, nothing is as frightening as the Forgemaster in the Dawnguard DLC.

Who is the hardest person to kill in Skyrim?

Karstaag is the undisputed toughest enemy in all of Skyrim. This optional frost troll boss has his level locked at 90, with absolutely no scaling. His health is 4000, and his regeneration rate is better than that of a normal troll.

Who is the best follower to kill in Skyrim?

Ralis Sedarys, The Most Justifiable Choice. Of all the followers in Skyrim none is more deserving of a grisly, sacrificial death than Ralis Sedarys. Ralis is the Dunmer at the head of the Kolbjorn Barrow excavation in Solstheim.