Why didn't Dutch trust Arthur?

Dutch Felt Everyone Was Betraying Him

As one of the original gang members, Arthur is one of the only people that can attempt to talk some sense into Dutch.

Why did Dutch betray Arthur?

Dutch Would Have Eventually Seen Arthur As A Threat In RDR2

Dutch wants to be the one in charge no matter what, and he wants his orders to be the law of the gang. Dutch would never relinquish control to anyone for any reason.

Why did Dutch start to hate Arthur?

Arthur tells Dutch, “I gave all I had… I did.” Dutch knows Arthur is loyal to him, but he can't admit how far he has fallen from grace for allowing Micah to grab power and control from him. He is deeply remorseful but can't admit it because he is too arrogant and proud to admit what he did wrong.

Did Dutch really care about Arthur?

The scene also speaks to the relationship between Dutch and Arthur Morgan in the game. Although the two outlaws are regularly at odds over Dutch's decision-making and constant planning, this detail suggests that Dutch does genuinely care about Arthur.

Did Dutch ever regret killing Arthur?

It's never fully stated if Dutch ended up regretting how things ended with his gang, and specifically Arthur. Despite whether or not he lost his mind, or was consumed by greed, it's hard to assume he never felt any regret or remorse over how things played out.

The real reason Dutch didn't trust Arthur anymore - Red Dead Redemption 2

Was Arthur loyal to Dutch?

Over time, Arthur transformed from a lost cause into Dutch's most dedicated enforcer. He is unwaveringly loyal to the gang, though the failed robbery in Blackwater troubles him.

What mental illness does Dutch Van Der Linde have?

Ego-maniac, gang leader and lover of the phonograph.

What did Dutch do after Arthur died?

Dutch himself is confronted by his former protégé, John, who chases him until Dutch is cornered near a cliff. After saying his piece, Dutch commits suicide, throwing himself from the cliff.

Who was the real rat in RDR2?

There are other signifiers that Abigail is the real rat like her reaction to Molly's confession and that Milton says that Micah's involvement only occurred after Guarma.

Why did John never mention Arthur?

Arthur's last dying efforts (in my playthrough) were to save the Marstons, and among his last words were to “not look back.” TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back.

Does Dutch feel bad when Arthur dies?

Dutch finally realized what a bad man he has been and that he has lost his true “son” Arthur. He couldn't abandon his life as an outlow but he also couldn't live with Micah.

Does Arthur see Dutch as a father?

Around 1877, Arthur and his siblings were picked up by Dutch Van Der Linde and Hosea Matthews. Viewing him as a surrogate father figure, Arthur came to share Dutch's vision of a life lived free from the constraints of civilization and the rule of law, becoming one of the first members of the Van Der Linde gang.

Who was Dutch's favorite?

Why is John regarded as Dutch's favorite when Arthur is clearly the favorite one.

What did Dutch do to the girl in Blackwater?

Heidi McCourt was a young woman who was murdered some time during the Blackwater Massacre by Dutch van der Linde via a gunshot to the head.

Is Dutch the real villain in RDR2?

Dutch van der Linde is the central antagonist of the Red Dead Redemption duology, part of the Red Dead franchise. He is the secondary antagonist of the 2010 video game Red Dead Redemption and the tritagonist turned major antagonist of its 2018 prequel Red Dead Redemption II.

Why did Dutch not want to save John?

Dutch, however, refused to rescue John, believing him to be a "doubter" and a traitor who he no longer cared for and was angered when Arthur and Sadie went behind his back and rescued him. During the final train robbery, Dutch once again left John to die, preferring if John was dead.

Who is the autistic guy in RDR2?

Bertram is first encountered in the Old Light Saloon at Van Horn Trading Post where he can be seen acting in a most peculiar way.

Did Dutch ever realize Micah was the rat?

Arthur reminded Dutch that before he took his last breath. He then accepted that Micah was the rat. Dutch didn't know Micah was playing him until the very end.

Is Abigail a rat?

Abigail was the RAT of RDR 2. Abigail was ambitious woman who wanted to leave a peaceful life with John and Jack. She never wanted to be part of gang bs and wanted to do to Tahiti or etc. You can see her desire to be real family mother and leave all these gang member out in many random gang conversations.

How old was Arthur Morgan when he died?

Arthur died at age 35 or 36, from tuberculosis. This is when the famous gunslinger Doc Holiday died in real life, who also had tuberculosis. With low honour, Arthur is a villain protagonist who only really cares about himself.

Did Dutch and Hosea raise Arthur?

25 Arthur Was Raised By Dutch And Hosea For Twenty Years

Although Arthur does have a biological father who raised him for quite some time, he's more a son of Dutch and Hosea than anything else.

How old was Arthur when Dutch took him in?

Fictional character biography

Arthur joined Dutch van der Linde's gang when he was fourteen, having lost his parents at a young age, and soon became Dutch's first protégé.

What illness does Hosea have rdr2?

Hosea Matthews may have been killed by Agent Milton, but it turns out he was also sick. Throughout the game, players can hear Dutch and other members of the gang discuss the fact that Hosea is suffering from what seems to be a certain type of lung disease.

Why did Dutch lose his mind?

In yet another job that goes south early into the game, the gang's fearless leader takes a major blow to the noggin and becomes dazed for the rest of the mission. The theory posits that Dutch was left with a brain injury as a result of the blow, and that this ultimately leads to his downward spiral.

How old was Dutch van der Linde when he died?

17 Dutch Van Der Linde, 44

Thanks to the Game of the Year guidebook for Red Dead Redemption, Dutch van der Linde has his age pinpointed to 1855. This would make Dutch 44 by the time of Red Dead Redemption 2, as the game is set in 1899.