Why you shouldn't take your child's phone away as punishment?

Taking away a teen's phone interferes with their social life, which can drive a wedge between parent and teen. It's helpful to make the punishment related to the misbehavior, so taking away your teen's phone for a misbehavior like breaking curfew doesn't usually make sense.

Is taking away a phone negative punishment?

Correct answer:

Positive punishment is when a bad thing is added and negative punishment is when a good thing is taken away. Since a good thing is taken away to decrease the likelihood that she will repeat her action, the removal of the phone is a negative punishment.

Why do parents take away phones as a punishment?

Mostly parents take away their kids' phone because their children were rude, talked back, came home late, didn't do their chores or some other totally non-phone related transgression. When a consequence is not related to the behaviour, it feels mean, harsh and hurtful.

How long should a parent take away a child's phone?

Taking the phone away for 24 hours can be a good starting place. What about safety issues? Letting your teen go to school without a phone in their pocket or allowing them to walk down the street without a phone isn't likely to cause them harm. After all, you likely grew up without access to a cell phone.

Is taking things away a good punishment for toddlers?

If you take away a privilege that your child doesn't really care about, it won't be an effective negative consequence. Pick something that is really going to impact your child, but not in a punitive way. Sometimes the loss of privilege can be a logical consequence.

Child Psychologist Says “Don’t take phones away as a punishment!”

Should parents take away cell phones as a punishment?

Threatening to take away your teen's phone may seem like a great way to get them to do something. But it's usually not a good choice as a punishment. When you take away their phone, you're turning off the television, banning games, taking away their ability to talk with friends, and grounding them all at once.

Does taking things away from kids work as punishment?

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but the tried-and-true discipline method of taking away video-games, a favorite toy, or whatever else is largely ineffective and, in fact, counter-productive.

Do my parents have the right to take my phone?

If the phone is your property, your parents - or anyone else - can not legally take it from you. On the other hand, if your parents are paying the monthly bills for the phone, they have the right to stop paying for it.

What do I do if my mom takes away my phone?

Should a parent check a child's phone?

Responsible parents must protect kids from potential harm. Monitoring your children's phone activities and messages is a significant part of that responsibility. The fact is most of the time children spend using phones will be online, where anyone can publish anything.

Should I take my 15 year olds phone at night?

The bottom line: When parents take away teens' cell phones at night, they're helping to ensure this natural sleep process can occur, so their teenager can get a decent's night rest. In the case of your daughter, the “trust” line is a trap. Don't go there. This is about providing a safe environment for your family.

Is it OK to read your child's text messages?

Reading your child's text messages is not that different than eavesdropping or reading their diary.” She advises parents to stay in their lane by steering clear of needless snooping, whether trying to find out what your kids are saying or who they are hanging out with.

Why children should not be given phones?

Kids with cell phones are likely to spend too much time on them, keeping them from doing more productive things like exercising and reading. There is increasing evidence of addiction to electronic devices, which like any other kind of addiction is destructive.

Is taking things away a good punishment?

Stop Stacking Consequences

James Lehman in The Total Transformation® Program tells us that you can't punish a kid into better behavior. So while it's certainly tempting, taking everything away from your child is unlikely to be effective in changing behavior.

Why you shouldn't take things away as punishment?

As a reactive form of punishment, taking away privileges seems random and fails to establish the connection between a behavior and a consequence," Fox notes. "When set up in advance, it gives the child a choice — if they don't make their bed, they are choosing to not be allowed to play with their LEGOs.

What type of punishment is taking something away?

Negative punishment: something is “taken away” from the mix that makes the behavior less likely to continue or reoccur (i.e., something pleasant is removed from the subject to discourage their behavior).

What is cold mother syndrome?

Emotionally absent or cold mothers can be unresponsive to their children's needs. They may act distracted and uninterested during interactions, or they could actively reject any attempts of the child to get close. They may continue acting this way with adult children.

Can parents shut your phone off?

Turn off Android phones

Google's Family Link app allows you to schedule a span of time for the phone to be off, such as bedtime. But you can also completely lock the device so kids can't even get into it.

How emotionally absent parents affect a child?

Symptoms Of Being Raised By Emotionally Unavailable Parents

Being raised by an emotionally unavailable parent or guardian can lead to a life of unstable friendships, strings of failed relationships, emotional neediness, an inability to self-regulate, provide for yourself, and identity confusion.

At what age should you give your child privacy?

By age six, most kids understand the concept of privacy, and may start asking for modesty at home. Here's what you can do to honour your child's privacy. Be supportiveA child's demand for privacy signals their increasing independence, says Sandy Riley, a child and adolescent therapist in Toronto.

How do you discipline a disrespectful 12 year old?

Should I check my 15 year olds phone?

“Does your child's perceived right to privacy supersede their safety? It's 100 percent your right to check their devices,” said Bill Wiltse, President of Child Rescue Coalition. Child predators want to invade children's lives, an abuse that they may never recover from.

What is cruel punishment for a child?

These include punishment which belittles, humiliates, denigrates, scapegoats, threatens, scares or ridicules the child. Corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading forms of punishment take place in many settings.

What should you not do when punishing your child?

What is the most damaging thing to do to a child?

Ellen Perkins wrote: "Without doubt, the number one most psychologically damaging thing you can say to a child is 'I don't love you' or 'you were a mistake'.