Did Dobby break Harry's promise?

Dobby broke his promise.

Now it's just tragic, because Dobby returned to save Harry's life one last time and died doing it.

Did Dobby break an unbreakable vow?

Dobby died because he made an unbreakable vow to Harry to not save him ever again, in CoS. I know he didn't but, he did promise. And he did break it.

Why did Dobby break his promise?

He was really concerned and worried about the wizarding world.

Why did Harry make Dobby promise to not save him?

Harry knew he never showed Dobby enough appreciation, and the guilt he felt over his death made him understand the far-reaching harm of the Death Eaters' lust for death. He never got to make things up to Dobby and never got to say goodbye to the house-elf who idolized him.

What did Dobby promise to Harry?

Dobby Never Made A Direct Promise To Harry Potter

It may have been inferred but Dobby never made a direct promise to his friend. In fact, Dobby saved him on multiple other instances before Deathly Hallows, such as giving him gillyweed for the Triwizard Tournament.

DID DOBBY DIE AS A RESULT OF BREAKING HIS PROMISE TO NEVER SAVE HARRY POTTER - HARRY POTTER THEORY

Why did Dobby sabotage Harry?

Dobby didn't want harry to go back to hogwarts because the Draco's father was planning to take Dumbledore out of the headmaster position and purge the school of students who are muggle born at the same time. Harry would have been in grave danger if he went to hogwarts.

Why didn t Hermione help Harry save Dobby?

Dobby's injuries were too severe for him to be saved. Magic has its limits. Also, Hermione was not in great shape herself, having been tortured by Bellatrix. She also lacked the advanced medical training, though it really wouldn't have mattered if she were trained as Dobby was beyond help.

What is Dobby's most famous line?

8 “Bad Dobby!

This Dobby quote is definitely one of the character's most well-known catchphrases. He yells it whenever he does something he assumes he shouldn't have, and then attempts to bang his head on any surface he can find.

Why didn t Harry just lie to Dobby?

Why didn't Harry just lie to Dobby saying he won't go to Hogwarts in The Chamber of Secrets? Because in many respects, a house elf is more powerful than witch or a wizard which Harry knew that Dobby would come to know for sure if he lied to him.

Why was Dobby free when Harry gave him a sock?

Socks are an important symbol for Dobby, as it represents his freedom from slavery. In the Harry Potter series, house elves are immediately freed from enslavement if their master gives them clothing.

Did Harry Potter care about Dobby?

Dobby Proudly Gave His Life to Save His Friend

Since then, Harry and Dobby have fostered a powerful friendship, and Harry eventually freed Dobby from Malfoy's servitude.

What broken promise kills Dobby?

Dobby's Broken Promise Cost Him His Life

In his efforts to save his friends, he paid the ultimate sacrifice when Bellatrix threw a knife just as Dobby apparated, stabbing him. Dobby's broken promise as he tried to protect Harry one last time ultimately led to him paying the price.

Why did Dobby love Harry so much?

Dobby loved Harry even before they met, because House-elves saw Harry Potter as the one who made life better for them when he made Voldemort go away. Harry's offer to help the kind little elf only confirms Dobby's idea that Harry is the best person in the universe.

Could Snape have saved Dobby?

For a wound like Dobby's, it was unlikely that either thing could have saved him. Also, the act of apparition is a highly taxing activity. The fact that Dobby was able to apparate three people plus himself while bleeding heavily, it would have been a miracle for him to survive.

What is Dobby weakness?

He is a true hero: the house-elf Dobby, with his weakness for articles of clothing that take getting used to, proper chutzpah and sometimes unusual methods of problem solving.

How old was Dobby when he died?

So then another 9 years because he was alive when Harry Potter started in 1990. Then he sadly passed away in 1998. So in total he is about 37 years old.

Did Dobby save Harry's life?

Dobby broke his promise.

Now it's just tragic, because Dobby returned to save Harry's life one last time and died doing it.

What does Dobby do when Harry doesn t listen to his warning?

We learn that Dobby wants to prevent Harry from returning to Hogwarts, as danger awaits him there. Harry protests, but Dobby will only respond by nodding or shaking his head. Their dialogue is interrupted by Dobby stopping to bang his head once more.

What was Dobby trying to warn Harry about?

Dobby finally told Harry why he was there - he had a warning: he shouldn't go back to Hogwarts School in September because he would be in danger.

What did JK Rowling say about Dobby?

This year, Rowling is is sorry for, “for killing someone who didn't die during the Battle of Hogwarts, but who laid down his life to save the people who'd win it.” “I refer, of course, to Dobby the house elf,” Rowling wrote on Twitter.

What was Dobby's last word?

When Dobby's last words before dying in Harry's arms are "Such a beautiful place, to be with friends. Dobby is happy to be with his friend, Harry Potter."

Why is Dobby's death the saddest?

One factor that makes both Cedric and Dobby's deaths exceptionally tragic is their innocence. Cedric and Dobby both died like Lily and James, attempting to protect Harry from a Death Eater. Unlike the other characters (like Dobby) who died for Harry, Cedric did so unknowingly.

Why did Harry Potter want to bury Dobby without magic?

Why didn't Harry use magic to bury Dobby? Dobby was a dear friend to Harry, so he wanted to provide him with a proper burial. Hence, he refused to use magic to bury him.

Why didn t Hermione get Ravenclaw?

And this is why Hermione does not fit into Ravenclaw, since she lacks their creativity of thought. When you also add in her fearlessness and her strong convictions about right and wrong, which are inherently Gryffindor traits, then there was even less of a chance she'd end up wearing blue and bronze.

What did Bellatrix do to Hermione?

After being on the run from a bunch of Snatchers, the gang were taken to Malfoy Manor, where Bellatrix proceeded to torture Hermione using the Cruciatus Curse. It was a testament to Hermione's toughness that she was able to walk away without lasting damage.